SEARCH
Dynamic Clarity ConsultingDCC Group
Author: (to be named on revision) · First published: 2023-04-27 · Last checked: 2026-09-29 · Original: Japanese
This page is written for owners and business-development managers of Japanese companies considering an acquisition or business succession in ASEAN. Plain-text version (.md)

M&A & business succession Knowledge & Guides › M&A & business succession › Southeast Asia M&A Explained, Vol. 1: Share valuation (Basics: why valuation matters)

Southeast Asia M&A Explained, Vol. 1: Share valuation (Basics: why valuation matters)

In the “Southeast Asia M&A Explained” series, M&A specialists based on the ground and focused on ASEAN share useful information for Japanese companies looking to acquire, covering what to consider and what to watch out for. This first instalment focuses on the share valuation process within M&A and explains why valuation matters.

The significance of share valuation

In M&A, share valuation is of great significance in determining the final price at which the buyer acquires the target company. Beyond that, for a listed company it is also important in explaining the deal not only to stakeholders such as the buyer’s shareholders and creditors, but also to the stock exchange and regulators with jurisdiction. Share valuation, including the process by which the value was determined, is also an important area for the audit firm and is subject to strict scrutiny. What about the seller? For a company whose shares are held by the founding family, for example, it is used as a tool for confirming the family’s intentions before selling the shares; for an owner-manager, it is used to confirm the value of the business built up so far and as a tool for deciding whether to sell the company to a third party. Furthermore, for the board of directors entrusted with running the company, share valuation is an indispensable step in fulfilling its accountability to shareholders regarding the recoverability of the investment through M&A and the appropriateness of the sale price.

To achieve these purposes, an independent external valuation specialist carries out an objective assessment of the value of the target company: this is “share valuation”.

The significance of share valuation

There are five main points to decide before formally starting a share valuation.

1) The company to be valued

In some cases, the target being acquired or sold through M&A is a single company; in others, the structure is complex, with several subsidiaries and affiliates. Before carrying out a share valuation, it is important first to map out the capital structure and decide what is in scope. The scope must also be determined with weight given not only to capital relationships but also to the actual functional links between the businesses.

A common failure is where an owner’s personal company outside the parent–subsidiary capital structure performs important functions for the business. Even if the shares of the company excluding it are acquired, there may be serious doubt as to whether the business plan drawn up by the seller can be achieved. To avoid discovering late in the deal negotiations that such a company has been left out of the scope of the valuation, forcing the valuation to be redone and causing major schedule delays, it is necessary to check both capital links and functional business links thoroughly in advance before deciding which companies fall within the scope of the valuation.

2) Timing of the valuation

As mentioned in “1. The significance of share valuation”, the purpose of the valuation changes what is expected of the specialist and how in-depth the specialist’s procedures are (and, in turn, the specialist’s fee).
Apart from materiality, these also vary depending on who carries out the share valuation and at what phase. For example, a valuation by the seller and one by the buyer will naturally produce different results, because their expectations, synergies and understanding of the business and industry differ. In terms of phase, results also differ depending on whether it is the first half of the deal, such as when submitting a letter of intent or a first-round bid, or the second half, such as when negotiating the share purchase agreement or submitting a final bid, because the amount of information available differs.
Understanding that the result of a share valuation changes depending on when it is carried out, decide the timing of the valuation (in some cases carrying it out more than once).

3) Reviewing the materials used for the valuation

Typical materials include the target company’s historical financial information and business plan. In share valuation in particular, the valuation is based on uncertain information about the future, so small deviations, errors or differences in understanding in the assumptions have a large impact on the result. Historical financial results that have already been finalised are therefore indispensable for verifying the reliability and accuracy of forecast information.
There are also specialists who verify the process of preparing such forward-looking information and the reasonableness of the assumptions used. However, while they are experts in share valuation, they are not experts in the target company and its industry, so a review of materials by such specialists is not necessarily sufficient. It must not be forgotten that the seller or buyer, as industry professionals, should also scrutinise closely how well developed the forward-looking information at the heart of the business and its management is.

4) Valuation date

It is desirable to base the valuation on the most recent possible date, but especially in small deals the target company’s financial reporting may be inadequate, and it is not uncommon for valuation at the ideal date to be difficult. In particular, if the company only closes its accounts annually and a valuation can therefore only be made at a date far in the past, the buyer’s decision-making body will suspect that the seller or target company has something to hide, and a great deal of effort will be needed after the valuation to re-check the target company’s performance up to the date of the share purchase agreement.

5) Valuation method

As explained in detail below, there are three broad valuation approaches, the market approach, the income approach and the cost approach, each with several valuation methods. Which method is best suited to valuing the target company’s shares depends on economic conditions, the state of the target’s industry and the target’s business model. Basically, the share valuation specialist decides on the method after an overall review (sometimes adopting several methods at once).

Key points: five things to decide before valuing a company

Approaches to share valuation

We noted above that share valuation should be determined by taking into account the characteristics of the business, the purpose of the valuation and other factors as a whole. Below we outline the general valuation approaches and the typical valuation methods under each.

The first is the income approach. This values a company on the basis of the profits or cash flows it is expected to generate in future. In theory, a company’s value is determined by its future earning capacity, so the income approach is regarded as the most common and theoretically sound valuation approach. Typical methods under the income approach are as follows.

DCF (Discounted Cash Flow) method

A method that discounts the cash flows a company is expected to generate in future to present value at the weighted average cost of capital, and deducts net interest-bearing debt at the valuation date

APV (Adjusted Present Value) method

A method that discounts future cash flows at the cost of equity instead of the weighted average cost of capital, adds the tax shield from debt, and deducts net interest-bearing debt

Capitalised earnings method

A method that assumes the company will earn a constant profit into the future and capitalises that profit at a fixed capitalisation rate

The second is the market approach. This values a company indirectly by comparison with similar listed companies or similar transactions. Where similar listed companies or transactions exist, the market approach is considered to have a degree of objectivity. Typical methods under the market approach are as follows.

Comparable company method

A method that calculates multiples based on the share prices of listed companies similar to the target in business scale and activities, and applies those multiples to the target

Comparable transaction method

A method that calculates multiples based on the transaction values of similar past transactions, and applies those multiples to the transaction in question

The third is the cost approach. This values a company by its net asset value, i.e. total assets less total liabilities on the balance sheet. The cost approach mainly derives a company’s static value, but it is generally easy to understand, useful for eliminating future uncertainty, and has traditionally been adopted as a corporate valuation approach. The typical method is as follows.

Adjusted net asset method

A method that makes the necessary adjustments to the assets and liabilities on the balance sheet and adds or deducts unrealised gains and losses to arrive at adjusted net asset value

After reviewing the share values calculated using the three approaches above, the final share price is generally decided through an overall assessment based on a comparison of the respective results. The following methods of overall assessment can be considered.

Single-method approach

A method that adopts one particular valuation method on its own

Combined approach

A method that adopts several valuation methods, sets a range for each result, and reaches a conclusion taking into account where the results overlap

Weighted approach

A method that adopts several valuation methods and reaches a conclusion by averaging the results with a set weighting for each

Key points: approaches to share valuation

First approach: the income approach
e.g. DCF (Discounted Cash Flow) method, APV (Adjusted Present Value) method, capitalised earnings method

Second approach: the market approach
e.g. comparable company method, comparable transaction method

Third approach: the cost approach
e.g. adjusted net asset method

Based on the results of the three approaches above, an overall assessment is made using the single-method, combined or weighted approach

What price should you buy or sell at? Valuing investment value, including synergies

If deals were agreed at the amount calculated by the share valuation, M&A would seem a very simple transaction. However, the buyer must verify thoroughly, within limited time, whether it can really grow the acquired company, whether there are latent risks, and how much synergy there is with its own business, while the seller aims to sell the company to the prospective buyer offering the best price and terms. The M&A transaction price is the compromise point at which the buyer’s “investment value” and the seller’s “sale value” meet, so the results of the share valuations carried out by each side and the actual transaction price often differ.

The buyer’s “investment value” rarely values the target company on a standalone basis; it also includes the expected value arising from synergies created with the buyer’s own business after the M&A. In a valuation using the commonly adopted income approach, the business plan is prepared not on a rough calculation that “this much synergy will arise over the next ten years”, but on detailed estimates of how much future cash inflow from post-integration synergies will arise in which year, and how much the related costs such as staff costs and system integration costs (future cash outflows) will be in which year. The feasibility of such synergies must also be taken into account when preparing the business plan and estimating future cash flows. In practice, therefore, especially when calculating the buyer’s M&A budget, such investment value assessment, and not only the share valuation of the target, is an important point.

In Part 2, “Share valuation (Basics: valuation methods)”, we will look at the approaches to share valuation in detail.

As a first step in valuing shares in Southeast Asia, GPC offers a simple share valuation tool that you can use free of charge. Please do try it.

You can obtain a simple share valuation report in the following three steps.
(1) Enter 20 items about the target company (e.g. industry, revenue, profit)
(2) The simple share valuation tool calculates the result on the spot
(3) The simple share valuation report is sent to you by email

Use the valuation tool here
https://dcc-gr.com/valuation/

This article was first published on our website on 2023-04-27 and moved to the new site format on 2026-09-29. It is an English version of the original Japanese text. The date it was last checked is shown above. Rules and tax rates change, so please check the latest official information before making decisions.

M&A (for buyers)

From finding acquisition targets in ASEAN to valuation, negotiation and post-merger integration, our specialists on the ground work alongside you.

See the service

Ask about this article

If you want to check how this applies to your own situation, please get in touch. A member of our team replies directly.

info@dcc-gr.com

Related pages