This page is written for finance and accounting staff thinking about a Singapore company’s tax and accounting in relation to its Japanese head office. Plain-text version (.md)
Accounting & tax Knowledge & Guides › Accounting & tax > Topic 10: [Anti-tax-haven rules] How to think about tax when planning to expand into Singapore (including tax avoidance)
Topic 10: [Anti-tax-haven rules] How to think about tax when planning to expand into Singapore (including tax avoidance)
Many tax accounting firms, JETRO and others have covered the definition of “foreign subsidiaries, etc.” and the capital and transaction tests under Japan’s anti-tax-haven rules (CFC rules), so here we would like to focus on a more practical way of thinking that is useful when planning to expand into Singapore. (The following assumes that readers have already looked at the tests under the anti-tax-haven rules.)
[Anti-tax-haven rules]
How to think about tax when planning to expand into Singapore including tax avoidance)
Feature
Court cases to look at before getting into practice
In the past, the anti-tax-haven rules rarely led to litigation unless a case was very large, but over the last four to five years court rulings have finally begun to appear. Care is therefore needed when conducting specific overseas transactions, particularly when expanding into these countries or into countries that cut corporate tax to attract companies.
2017: Denso (Singapore subsidiary) - Supreme Court ruling
2021: Sanrio (Hong Kong and Taiwan) - Tokyo District Court
2022: Mizuho Bank (Cayman Islands, British territory) - Tokyo High Court
2022: Nissan (Bermuda, British territory) - Tokyo High Court
Studying cases like these makes the concrete YES/NO answers clearer, so it is worth reviewing the case law.
I run an e-commerce business in Japan, and on the advice of a tax accountant I know, I would like to set up a local company in Singapore with a “logistics headquarters function”, book the sales currently recorded in Japan in the Singapore company, and accumulate them as future profits. Is this really possible?
Frankly, enquiries like this are not uncommon when you are based in Singapore. Designing the company simply as a “logistics base” calls for caution. So, to design your base correctly, what preparation is needed, and why most cases are not done properly. We will also explain clearly how this relates to the “anti-tax-haven rules” in the heading and to tax avoidance.
Why are most cases not done properly?

- A design that merely spreads the current Japanese company’s profits
First, take a close look at Figure 1. It is a simple design in which the Singapore company has just been inserted into the flow of transactions. And because Mr A continues to live in Japan, the substance test for foreign subsidiaries is not met either; all that changes is the addressee on vouchers and invoices. Around ten years ago, so-called “paper companies” like this proliferated in Singapore, but they are no longer the trend at all. - For a domestic e-commerce business in Japan, the source of revenue is in Japan
Looking at the far left of Figure 1, the e-commerce business’s revenue comes from sales on the Amazon Japan and Rakuten platforms, and you should clearly recognise that the business serves Japanese consumers. As we touch on later in the “Solution” sections, it is important as a business owner to respect the fundamental principle that profits earned from Japanese consumers are, in principle, taxed in Japan. - What about having someone else become shareholder or director?
This, too, is in principle NO. For example, one casually suggested idea is to have someone else become the shareholder of the Singapore company (lending a name as nominee shareholder) and treat it as an advisory arrangement with a wholly unrelated third party. As also mentioned in the [Transfer pricing] topic, the tests under the anti-tax-haven rules include a management and control test, and in terms of who actually ran the business, that would be Mr A. In Singapore, besides the court cases mentioned at the beginning, there is a case known as the “rented office case”. In that case the rented office was the focus as the place of management and control, but viewed on a substance basis it was a rather grey arrangement, and it is a design that would not hold up today.
For transfer pricing rules, please see the following.
So, is there any tax value in Mr A setting up a Singapore company?
As a matter of principle, as things stand, there is no value, we can say with confidence. The reasons are that, for tax purposes, the company would certainly be caught by the anti-tax-haven rules, so (1) profits booked in the Singapore company would be taxable under Japanese tax law, and (2) the Singapore company’s running costs would be pure cash outflow, increasing overall costs compared with operating the Japanese company alone.
However, by raising your “business mindset” just a little, it can also become a catalyst for expanding the group’s business. There are indeed Japanese people in Singapore who have grown their sales in this way and significantly increased their overall profits.
Without being misled by “quick-fix” ideas like the one in Figure 1, and with a business mindset, we explain the following three STEPs for reorganising your thinking. We hope they help your future planning.
Solution 1: Consider a partnership with a local business partner (management and control test)
For an e-commerce business, Singapore is an ideal base for multilingual operations, from which you can target huge markets: the “English-speaking world”, the “Chinese-speaking world” and, thanks to its location, “Southeast Asia”. So, as in Figure 2, by partnering with a local business partner (who already has overseas e-commerce platforms) and entrusting overseas-sourced products to Mr B’s company, Mr A can create a flow of cost reductions through volume purchasing, plus sales growth by wholesaling domestically sourced products overseas. (Maximising the red circles.)

First, taking this step lets you prepare for expansion with overseas markets in view.
In Figure 1 above, Mr A was the shareholder and manager of the Singapore company, but in Figure 2 the transactions are with Mr B, a business partner living in Singapore, so the “management and control test”, one of the economic activity tests under the anti-tax-haven rules in the title, does not apply. Mr B is purely the owner and director of the Singapore company, and Mr A would not interfere in its management.
Solution 2: Consider a partnership with a local business partner (substance test)
As with the management and control test above, under the “substance test”, another of the economic activity tests, the Singapore company’s business activities are conducted independently by Mr B in Singapore under contracts with Amazon (Singapore and US) and major local e-commerce platforms such as Shopee, so the Singapore company would not become a foreign affiliated company in relation to Mr A’s Japanese business.
Solution 3: Setting up an overseas digital marketing company as a JV with Mr B
This is the STEP after implementing Solution 1. Given the nature of e-commerce, we often see cases develop along the following lines: once domestic sales in Japan and overseas wholesale transactions have grown through the partnership with the local partner, a JV is set up in Singapore together with Mr B to strengthen the overseas markets, which offer more growth potential.
Strengthening overseas markets brings various additional costs and tasks, such as digital marketing advertising costs, forwarding, payment agency services in the target regions and provisions for collecting payment for goods. This JV must have genuine business substance for tax purposes. Even within Southeast Asia, in many emerging countries cash on delivery (COD) is the main e-commerce payment method, so provision-type transactions also arise.
As a result, a natural business flow emerges in which sales earned in overseas markets are used as investment in this JV and applied to day-to-day advertising and staff costs. (See Figure 3.)

Cases like the above are not issues to consider only in terms of “transfer pricing rules”; you should decide how to expand into or move to Singapore after properly checking other tax law issues as well. Now let us examine, from a business perspective, the points to watch when expanding into Singapore, focusing on the field of “transfer pricing rules”.
The future of the anti-tax-haven rules
As mentioned at the beginning, Southeast Asian countries are now following Singapore’s success and competing to cut corporate tax rates to attract foreign investment. Overall, in terms of national infrastructure, access to talent, currency stability, education levels and so on, we believe Singapore’s advantage remains unchanged for now, but others will naturally catch up in future. Because of Singapore’s biggest drawbacks, its high costs and small market, some companies, not only Japanese but also other foreign companies, have begun choosing Bangkok, Kuala Lumpur and elsewhere as their Southeast Asian base.
| Country | Current effective (basic) tax rate |
| Singapore | 17% (from 20%: 2010) |
| Thailand | 20% (from 23%: 2016) |
| Malaysia | 24% (from 25%: 2016) |
| Indonesia | 22% (from 25%: 2020) |
| Philippines | 25% (from 30%: 2020) |
| Vietnam | 20% (from 22%: 2016) |
| Country | Current effective (basic) tax rate |
| Singapore | 17% (from 20%: 2010) |
| Thailand | 20% (from 23%: 2016) |
| Malaysia | 24% (from 25%: 2016) |
| Indonesia | 22% (from 25%: 2020) |
| Philippines | 25% (from 30%: 2020) |
| Vietnam | 20% (from 22%: 2016) |
Recently even the US has moved to 21%, and we are now in an environment where you cannot simply judge a country to be a “low-tax country” by looking at its headline effective rate (whether progressive taxation applies, or after preferential rates, etc.). In such an environment, it is easy to predict that the range of countries treated as tax havens from Japan’s perspective will widen and become ever more complex as it interacts with local tax systems. Future trends in Japanese corporate tax also need to be watched closely, including how far Japan can keep its economic environment attractive as business succession is driven by the wave of ageing in the Japanese economy.
This article was first published on our website on 2023-04-11 and moved to the new site format on 2026-09-29. It is an English version of the original Japanese text. The date it was last checked is shown above. Rules and tax rates change, so please check the latest official information before making decisions.
Accounting & Tax service
Our accountants handle bookkeeping, year-end accounts and corporate tax filing for your Singapore company, and sort out the tax issues with your Japanese head office.
See the serviceAsk about this article
If you want to check how this applies to your own situation, please get in touch. A member of our team replies directly.